Who Pays What When One Partner Earns More

If there is one type of inequality in a couple that we cannot do much about, it would be the financial inequality. In most cases, one person in a couple earns more than the other. It happens in our family, and it probably happens in your family as well.

So how do you budget when you and your partner live together, have bills and housing to pay for, but contribute differently to the household budget? Who pays what?

The answer is: You share. One way or another, you share… But how?

50/50 is out the window here because it would suit the person with higher salary, but it would make the other half really struggle with the inequality.

In this post I am going through the 5 best ways to split, share, and budget your money as a couple when one of you earns more than the other. You can pick the one that resonates with you, but there are a few things to consider before choosing your favorite budgeting method.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, which means that if you sign up or make a purchase I might get a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my business. See full disclosure.

Before You Decide What To Do With You Money

You will be shocked at how many couples rarely talk about money, or avoid having a conversation about their wants and needs when it comes to finances.

It doesn’t help that most of us are kind of emotional and possessive when it comes to money. We spend so many hours hustling, usually doing a job we dislike, working around people we find annoying, so when that hard-earned money lands in our accounts, the last thing we want is someone chiming in with opinions on how to spend them.

And budgeting, paying and saving together will be a challenge from day one if you aren’t willing to have an honest conversation about it.

Here are a few things I would advise you to discuss:

  • Short- and long-term financial goals – What do you want to save or spend money on? Do you plan to pursue further education or a professional qualification that would require bigger financial investment?;
  • What are your financial values? Do you see money through the same lens?
  • Financial habits such as how often either of you overspends and your actual attitudes toward saving money (not what you say but what you do);
  • Establish financial awareness – do you know your salaries, spending and savings using near-exact numbers, not estimations?
  • Consider talking through scenarios such as: What happens if one of you loses a job? What do you do if one of you has to stay home to look after a baby (if kids are in your plans)? How would you approach spending around holidays, vacations and events? Do you plan on buying a home together?

There are no right answers to any of the questions and discussions above. The main reason you need to go through them is to see how aligned you are when it comes to money. If you are both honest with each other, these converstions will make your lives much easier because they can help stop you from overthinking situations and life challenges.

Now you can move on to the actual plan for handling expenses every month. Here are the 5 most common ways to budget as a couple.

how to handle money as a couple when one of you earns more

5 Ways to Budget as a Couple When One Gets Paid More

A Bit Of Everything and a Mindset Shift

This method might sound like a chaotic option, but it is what my husband and I do, and it has worked for us for the last 10 years. It is heavily based on mindset, and it is the most liberating and mentally easier way to handle money for us (dislaimer: personal opinion).

My husband and I don’t “share” and don’t “calculate” anything. We never sat down to calculate how much our bills and regular spending cost with the idea of splitting them in a “fair” way. What we both think and believe is that there is no “I” when it comes to family finances. It is never “I have a financial goal”, but “We have a financial goal.”

We both keep our own accounts, and we don’t have a joint account to work with. We each have bills assigned to our names, but we never calculate how much each of us pays compared to the other person. None of us has ever sat down to blame the other for paying less or having more money to spend.

Our money is “our” money, and if I run out of money in my account, my husband will transfer as much as I’ve asked for in a matter of minutes, without even asking what I need it for. This goes both ways. We don’t keep tabs on each other’s personal purchases, but we count on common sense. If something costs a bit more, we discuss the purchase in advance (not every single time, but most of the time).

We both had periods when one of us wasn’t making any money, and the other one was covering everything, including loans we had taken out before we met. And we have never felt like we “shouldn’t pay” for something the other has brought into the relationship – loans, credit cards, hobbies, or education…

When it comes to saving money, we also discuss who can set some money aside. We each have our own savings accounts and if I were to sit next to my husband and ask him how much he has in each of his accounts, he would open his bank app and show me everything. This also works both ways.

In fact, we share our progress with each other to receive praise and support for saving. We don’t hide purchases or financial goals.

Does it sound too good and like we’re saints?

At the beginning, I struggled with this approach to budgeting. Shortly after we met, 10 years ago, we decided that I should stay home and build a business (the blog you are reading right now). That left me with no income for nearly two years. My husband was covering absolutely everything during this time and never put a stop to anything I needed or wanted (and that was before we even got married).

After I started making a decent income with my blogs, my husband quit his job and stayed home for a year. I was making enough money to cover everything just like he had done before that.

Both experiences taught us to see money as something we both make or don’t make, spend, or save. Now, it comes naturally to us, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. I know this approach isn’t for everyone, but after being in relationships where we tried to split every penny to make things “fair,” I’ve learned that this just feels much more natural to me.

Now, on to the other four ways to split bills.

how to split the bills when one earns more

Joint Account

Open a joint account for your salaries and expenses. Bills, rent/mortgage, spending, and subscriptions go out of that joint account. You use it for grocery shopping and personal expenses, such as clothes, hobby expenses, and date nights.

This is the first extreme on this list, and while I like to think that extremes are never good, this one might be the perfect option for many couples. It would mainly depend on your cultural backgrounds, money values, and habits.

Simply put, if you come from families where your parents had joint accounts and always kept their money together, this would feel like the natural way to do it in your relationship. If you both don’t overthink every dollar that gets spent and you are comfortable with having all your money in the same pot, this is your method.

The downside is that you have less individual control over your money when both of you have equal access to the account. And as much as I want to assure you that thinking about a potential split-up or divorce is very grim of you, the reality is that you can never know. So keep that in mind.

Proportional or Income-Based Splitting

This seems to be a very convenient option for many couples. You each keep your personal accounts where your income arrives, but open one joint account for bills, rent/mortgage and any other shared expenses. Then you both transfer money into that account to pay for those expenses.

Do this to figure out how much you should contribute to that joint account: Calculate the combined income and see what percentage of that total each of you earns (for example you bring 60% of the total income and your partner brings the other 40%). That is how you split the expenses as well – you pay 60% of them, and your partner pays the other 40%.

The disadvantage of this approach is that 60% of your income might still leave you with good amount of money left over to spend. At the same time, your partner might struggle to cover their share and still have left over to spend on themselves. This is a conversation you need to have in advance. You also want to talk about who pays for groceries and what happens when you go out together.

Assigned Bills

Here, you start the same way: You split the income and contribute to shared expenses based on your respective income shares, but you never open a joint account. Each of you gets “assigned” a bill and has to pay it from their own account. For example, your can cover the mortgage and the broadband while your partner pays for gas, electricity and water. You pay for Netflix and Amazon Prime while your partner covers date nights.

The downside of this one is that you might end up calculating and overthinking who spends more. Keep in mind that, when you have a family, contributions can never be measured or divided equaly, no matter how much you try. One of you will always do, earn, or spend more in some areas than the other and that is normal.

ways couples handle money when one partner earns more budgeting for couples

One Person Pays it All and The Other Saves

This is an approach I rarely see, but it is the exact method my husband and I used, two years ago so we could save for a down payment on our house. We did it in under six months. Now we budget a bit differently (I explained the exct method above).

The title is self-explanatory: One of you, usually the person who earns more, covers everything – bills, loans, mortgage/rent, groceries and any additional expenses. The other person saves their salary – probably not all of it, but most of it.

This is a method that requires you to be in a good financial position as a family, and it isn’t something every couple can do. But if you can, this approach will allow you to build up your savings for an emergency fund, a down payment, or any other goal quickly.

Instead of a Conclusion

The way we budget our family money isn’t the right way for everyone, and I certainly cannot tell you that it is easy or that you should even try it.

The right way to budget your money as a couple is the way that leaves both of you feeling comfortable, confident that everything is paid, and able to count on each other to do the right thing. It should also be a system that makes you stronger as a couple and doesn’t leave either of you struggling or feeling like you’re somehow less than your partner.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top