Subscription Creep: The Hidden Cost of Small Monthly Payments

My husband used to annoy me so much by asking to pay for everything in one payment. According to him, there is rarely any room for monthly payments, and even if we have to pay hundreds of pounds, he would gladly hand the money over and forget about it for the next 11 months.

This tiny money habit used to drive me crazy for years, until I realized that what he was doing made more sense … for fewer people.

Because according to this UK government article from April 2026 there are just around 155 million active subscriptions bringing subscirption spend to £26 billion per year. 1.3 million people are getting caught by unexpected renewals and over 3.5 million are being quietly moved from free to paid monthly subscriptions without any warnings.

But this isn’t just a British problem.

In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission estimated that around 83% of American consumers have at least one subscription, with the average subscriber having approximately 4.5 subscriptions. Based on these figures, the FTC estimated that Americans collectively have around one billion subscriptions. You can read the FTC’s analysis of subscription contracts and consumer spending.

And while I can confidently say that companies are taking advantage of people’s carelessness and desire to use services “right now” as long as they hand over just a few dollars (or more) monthly, I am aware that this is our fault as consumers.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, which means that if you sign up or make a purchase I might get a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my business. See full disclosure.

how to pay for monthly subscriptions

The Subscription Creep

It deserves its name. Think about it.

We have gym subscriptions, streaming subscriptions, fitness apps, book reading subscriptions, delivery services, software, entertainment subscriptions, and more. Nearly everything has become a subscription.

Add that to the minimum monthly payments of your credit cards, your loans’ monthly payments, and your bills (that are, surprise surprise, monthly payments as well) and you end up living a subscription life where everything you touch, listen to, eat, and move through is something you need to pay for this month or you lose it.

I know, this is a grim way to look at things, but it doesn’t mean it isn’t a realistic problem we actively close our eyes to. We keep giving our money away to tens of companies, month after month, often without even realizing it.

And who am I to talk about it?! After I gave birth to my son, I didn’t cancel my Kindle subscription for 8 months, just because I was hoping to get back to reading, so I kept paying but never used it. That was £80 down the drain.

Not everything needs to be paid for yearly, of course. There are services that are better off paid monthly, such as software, gym memberships, meal kit deliveries, and online learning platforms.

But if I have been paying Netflix for the last 7 years, there is a good chance I will be using it for the next 12 months as well, so a yearly subscription would make more sense. But no, streaming services don’t want to ask for £96 once a year (12 times £7.99) because “we can cancel a monthly subscription any time we want”, and not because it is a mind game where the average person never calculated how much they pay a year for every subscription.

We Hate Creadit Cards, But They Aren’t The Worse Debt Anymore

I used to work in a bank in the 2010s. Our main monthly target was to make as many people get a credit card as possible. If they had one credit card already, we were supposed to do our best to make them get another one or increase the limit of the one they had. The best quality of a bank employee was to be able to “sell” credit cards to people.

It wouldn’t be a surprise that most people actually hate credit cards. They have them and they hate them. I have one and I am not happy with it.

Still… a credit card can be difficult to pay off, but but there is a clear end point. Once you fill it up, you can still have it without using it. Even if you use it, you will get that interest-free period of time to pay it off without having to pay interest on it as well.

In other words – there is an end to it, and there is a good way of using it that doesn’t necessarily drain your account.

Things aren’t the same with subscriptions. The rule is very simple: once you sign up, you pay or you lose the service and all its perks that you have kind of got used to having.

Yes, in my professional opinion, subscriptions are, in a way, worse than the traditional debt we’ve all learned to dislike.

And the main reason is that we don’t see it as debt. We hand over our hard-earned money without a second thought because we either consider life better with that service, or we simply forget that we have that subscurption.

Yes, £9.99 sounds like a worry-free number when a coffee in Starbucks costs nearly as much, and £119.88 sounds like a lot of money to pay for nearly 99% of the services you likely pay for.

This is called Price Framing and it is a marketing and psychological term – a name for something that is just an “illusion“. Marketers would even get to the point of saying that you pay for something just £0.33/day, which is almost a laughable amount, and you feel stupid for not wanting to say goodbye to just a few coins a day.

paying monthly for subscription budgeting for monthly payments

The Glass of Water Method

The Glass of Water method says that, when it comes to debt, I should always overpay the monthly payments, even if that is with just a few pennies more. I would always zero out my account on payday by transferring leftover money to a credit card.

The idea is that absolutely anything I add towards debt fills the glass, and paying the debt off earlier becomes unavoidable.

Well, things are exactly the same when it comes to subscriptions, just in a less cheerful way.

Because everything we allow to leak from our accounts with no second thought (literally) is something we are never seeing again, money that could’ve gone into our emergency fund, savings, or towards paying off the mortgage. But all those things are boring, and a streaming service or a fun game to play while waiting in a queue isn’t.

This Isn’t Shaming

In no way am I shaming anyone for having subscriptions, whatever those subscriptions are. I have a few things I pay for every month as well, and I don’t plan on canceling them.

But I am trying to raise awareness among people, especially at a time when the economy is unstable, income barely covers everything it should cover, and more and more families face the reality of living paycheck to paycheck.

subscription creep and why you are poor when paying monthly for eerything

Pay Attention, Not Subscriptions

We should all take a good look at what we pay for. Making a decision to keep a subscription or not, based on how much it gives us back isn’t the best one. It isn’t only about “Is it worht it?” anymore. There are thousands of good services we could subscribe to that are absolutely worth it.

But… how many “worth it” subscriptions are you paying for, month after month, that are slowly draining your funds away? Realising exactly what happens to your money, day after day, week after week, is called money-awareness, and I think we should all finally become money-aware.

Companies and marketers are fighting for our coins, and that is their job. They have the funds, ideas, and right to do their best and make us sign up for their services. I cannot fault them for fighting to be seen when I am also a small business owner and I do my best to make people come to my blog, read, and see the ads that pay my bills.

But the responsibility of where our money goes is always ours. Every penny, pound, dollar ,or cent we give to a subscription is something we are responsible for. Governments come up with regulations and awareness messages, but at the end of the day, our thumbs are pressing the “Subscribe” buttons left and right with no second thought, without reading through the T&C, and without checking if we can afford it.

How to Practice Money-Awareness

Let me circle back to the used-to-be-annoying habit my husband has: paying in one instalment for everything (if possible).

When you pay £10 monthly for a subscription or service, you would never see the total of £120 leaving your account. It will happen, eventually, but it will be a slow process that you will forget about in two months. However, when you pay the full £120 in advance, you feel the true consequences of that decision – the money is gone and you have budgeted for it (or you haven’t).

There are three things you could do to practice money awareness:

  • Notice => Do nothing differently, but calculate the annual cost of every subscription you have and write them somewhere you can see them often (your money planner, your calendar, your daily/monthly planner). Practice looking at that list every month, not to change anything, but to notice where your money goes.
  • Track => Create a subscription budget in your bank app. Most banks now offer the opportunity to give your payments a category. Create a category called “Subscriptions” for each regular monthly payment that is, indeed, a subscription. Every month (or every week) log into your bank app with the intention of checking how much you’ve spent in that category. Some subscriptions are quarterly or twice a year – include them as well.
  • Feel => For maximum awareness. Open a separate bank account that you only use for subscriptions. Calculate your total monthly subscription cost and manually transfer that amount into the account on payday. Let your subscriptions come out of that account. You can use your monthly planner to keep track of everything. Try this for three months and see how different it feels when you can actually watch the money being allocated to subscriptions rather than seeing individual payments quietly disappear from your main account. I’d be honest: this option is probably too much work for most people, but it can be an interesting experiment.

Whatever you choose, make sure you pay attention, not subscriptions only.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top